An unworn necklace, a single earring or an inherited ring can leave you wondering what to do with old jewelry. Before you look for a buyer, separate the pieces you’re ready to sell from the ones you want to keep or understand better.
Keeping, repairing, redesigning, gifting and donating are all reasonable choices. You can also set something aside until you know more about it or feel ready to decide.
Key Takeaways
- Sort pieces into keep, repair, sell and assess before contacting any buyer.
- Insurance values, appraisals and purchase offers measure different things.
- Each selling route trades payment certainty against potential return and effort.
- Compare the money you’d keep after every deduction, not the headline figure.
- Document everything, get terms in writing and verify payment before handing anything over.
Decide Which Pieces You’re Ready to Sell
Posts on this site may contain brand partnerships, promotional content, or affiliate links. I may earn a commission or fee if you click a link or purchase through these recommendations at no additional cost to you.
Lay everything out on a towel in good light and give each piece one of four labels. Treat them as starting points; you can change your mind once you learn more. If you’re tackling a bigger clear-out, it can help to declutter as a family so everyone weighs in on what stays.
Keep or pass on. If a piece has sentimental value, keeping it is a valid decision. Jewelers Mutual recommends holding on to pieces with a sentimental connection, and passing something to a relative who will wear it is another option. If you’d rather donate, ask the charity whether it accepts jewelry.
Repair or redesign. A broken clasp, missing stone or dated setting doesn’t automatically make a piece scrap. Before authorizing changes to an inherited item, find out who made it and roughly when, since some alterations can’t be undone.
Sell. This label belongs on pieces you no longer want and don’t plan to repair. A lone earring may still have metal value, but check whether a piece deserves assessment as jewelry before you send it to a metal buyer.
Set aside for assessment. Use this when the maker, age, materials or significance is unclear, such as costume jewelry from an older relative, a signature you can’t read or an unfamiliar stone. Neither costume nor broken jewelry should be dismissed without checking what it is.
Visible marks offer clues. A “14K” stamp indicates 14-karat gold, and a “375” mark indicates 9-karat gold. A number on its own doesn’t prove authenticity or tell you what a buyer will pay. Avoid home acid tests, scratching, removing stones or heavy polishing while identification is uncertain. Photograph each piece and its marks instead.
Work Out What Kind of Value You Need
“What is it worth?” can mean several different things, so pin down what each figure measures before comparing it with an offer.
Material value covers the metal and stones on their own. A precious-metal buyer may focus on weight and purity, while another buyer may also weigh the design, maker or resale appeal. Ask how each buyer treats stones rather than assuming every part counts toward the offer.
Resale value is what the piece could sell for secondhand. A business making a purchase offer also has to cover its costs, margin and risk, so its offer will sit below that figure.
Appraised value is an opinion. GIA describes fair market value as an appraiser’s view of what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, and that opinion doesn’t commit anyone to buy. Jewelers of America notes that most jewelry appraisals are prepared for insurance replacement, so an existing appraisal may reflect replacement cost rather than likely sale proceeds.
A confirmed offer is an amount you can accept under stated terms. A grading report won’t give you that figure, since GIA doesn’t put dollar values on gemstones or jewelry.
Before paying for an appraisal, consider what question it needs to answer and whether the cost makes sense for the item. Jewelers of America recommends getting quotes from several companies before choosing a gold buyer. An antique, signed piece or unidentified gemstone may need specialist assessment before you consider selling it for scrap.
Compare the Main Places to Sell Jewelry
There’s no single best place to sell jewelry. One UK specialist, Suttons & Robertsons, makes this point in this guide on where to sell jewellery, noting that the right route depends on what the piece is worth, how quickly you want to be paid, the fees, how certain the sale is and how much effort you want to put in.
| Route | Suits | When you’re paid | Main trade-off |
| Jeweler or specialist buyer | Branded, antique or gemstone pieces with resale appeal | Under the agreed purchase terms | The offer reflects the buyer’s costs and margin |
| Precious-metal buyer | Gold, silver or platinum where design adds little | After testing and acceptance | Design and stones may add little or nothing |
| Pawnbroker buying outright | Items the business accepts for purchase | Under the agreed sale terms | Confirm it’s a sale, not a loan |
| Consignment | Pieces with resale appeal you can wait to sell | After a completed sale, less deductions | Payment depends on a sale happening |
| Auction house | Collectible, signed, antique or high-value pieces | After the sale settles, less fees | Estimates aren’t guaranteed and lots can go unsold |
| Online marketplace | Pieces you can describe and photograph accurately | Per the platform’s payout schedule | You handle listing, shipping, questions and disputes |
Direct buyers give you a figure to accept. Expertise matters here. A buyer who regularly resells pieces like yours is more likely to value brand, collection, condition and resale demand than one focused mainly on gold weight. Ask each buyer whether its quote carries any obligation and who pays return shipping if you decline.
Consignment pays after a sale. The business sells on your behalf and keeps a commission. Rates vary by business and item, so get the rate in writing, and ask how long the business can hold the piece, whether it needs your permission to lower the price and what happens if it doesn’t sell.
Auction terms need to be agreed up front. Christie’s says its seller’s commission is agreed at consignment. Ask for the estimate, any reserve (the minimum price the piece can sell for) and charges for photography, insurance or unsold lots. An estimate is not an offer.
Online marketplaces put the work on you. Completed sales are a far better guide to value than asking prices, since a listed price may never be achieved. eBay’s US fee table lists a 15% final value fee for the relevant jewelry category on sales of $5,000 or less, and other fees may apply. General marketplaces often make the most sense for costume and lower-value pieces.
Check what a pawnbroker is offering. A pawn loan means borrowing against an item the lender holds, with repayment terms. If you want to sell, ask for an outright purchase price and check that the paperwork records a sale.
Ask what each business accepts before you travel or ship. Some buyers decline costume jewelry or loose stones, and some metal buyers don’t pay for stones, so get that in writing.
Compare the Amount You’d Keep
Compare the money you’d receive after deductions, not the headline figure. Use one row per item and route, recording the type of arrangement, whether the figure is a confirmed offer or depends on a later sale, the commission, any other costs, when payment is due and what happens if the piece doesn’t sell.
Net proceeds = offer or sale price minus commission and applicable costs, before tax.
For a consignment or auction, work through both the proposed price and a lower one. Keep costs you’d pay only if the piece goes unsold, such as return fees, separate from costs taken after a successful sale. A consignment estimate may leave more after commission than a direct offer, but only if a buyer pays the assumed price, so note the waiting time beside the figures. Ask a tax professional about any consequences that apply to your situation.
Protect Your Jewelry and Your Payment
Before a piece leaves your hands, confirm who will hold it, what they’ll do with it and how you’ll be paid or get it back.
Check the business. The FBI recommends confirming the legitimacy of any business, website or person involved in an online transaction. Verify contact details and read the written terms before shipping.
Document the handover. Photograph each piece, including marks and damage, and get an itemized receipt describing what you left and what the business agreed to do. Keep emails and messages.
Check shipping coverage. Tracking and insurance are separate features. Confirm your carrier’s declared-value limits and that the service covers jewelry at its full value. Some buyers offer insured collection, so confirm the coverage limit and that your shipment qualifies.
Verify payment. Confirm payment in your own account or on the selling platform rather than trusting a message or screenshot. The Federal Trade Commission warns sellers never to deposit a check for more than the selling price. A request to refund an “overpayment,” or pressure to ship before payment clears, is a reason to stop.
If you meet a private buyer, choose a busy public place in daylight, bring another adult and keep the piece out of sight until you’re ready.
Choose a Next Step Without Rushing
Your next step depends on whether you need a quick sale, more information or more time. If payment timing matters, compare confirmed offers from several suitable buyers, looking at the final amount and payment terms. If a piece may be collectible, get it assessed by a category specialist, auction department or independent appraiser first. If likely proceeds are modest, weigh the work of listing and shipping against what you’d keep, since a lower offer may suit you if it saves time.
If you’re still unsure, keep the piece out of the sale pile. You can gather information without committing to sell anything.
FAQ
What should I do first with old jewelry?
Sort each piece into keep, repair, sell or assess, then photograph anything you’re considering selling, including its marks.
Is an insurance appraisal what my jewelry will sell for?
Usually not. Most appraisals estimate replacement cost for insurance, which is typically higher than what a buyer will pay.
Is consignment better than selling outright?
Not always. Consignment can bring a higher price, but payment depends on a sale, and commission and waiting time can narrow the difference.
How can I avoid scams when selling jewelry?
Check the buyer’s legitimacy, get terms in writing, document the handover and confirm payment in your own account before releasing the piece.

